Cleveland-Cliffs Inc
2000 Annual Report
 
Company Profile
Core Values
Comparative Hightlights
Letter to Our Shareholders
Management's Discussion
2000 Versus 1999
1999 Versus 1998
Cash Flow
Capitalization
Iron Ore
Ferrous Metallics
Actuarial Assumptions
Environmental Costs
Market Risk
Forward Looking
Financial Information
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
Report of Ernst & Young
Quarterly Results of Operations
Cliffs Managed Mines
Eleven Year Summary
Investor & Corporate Information
Officers and Directors
Annual Report Home
 

 

MANAGEMENT'S  DISCUSSION

1999 Versus 1998
Net income for 1999 was $4.8 million, or $.43 per share, compared to 1998 net income of $57.4 million, or $5.06 per share. Year 1999 net income included favorable after-tax income adjustments of $4.4 million that related primarily to prior years’ state tax refunds (recorded as a reduction to cost of goods sold). Year 1998 net income included a $3.5 million favorable income tax adjustment related to audits of prior years’ federal tax returns. Excluding special items in both years, net income was $.4 million in 1999, a decrease of $53.5 million from 1998.

The $53.5 million decrease in net income before special items reflected lower income before income taxes of $73.9 million, partially offset by a $20.4 million decrease in income taxes. The decrease in pre-tax income before special items was primarily due to:

  • Negative pellet sales margin of $20.0 million in 1999 compared to a margin of $46.1 million in 1998, a decrease of $66.1 million summarized as follows:
  (In Millions)

 
      Increase

(Decrease)

  1999 1998 Amount Percent





Sales (Tons) 8.9 12.1 (3.2) (26)%





Revenue from product sales and services $316.1 $465.7 $(149.6) (32)%
Cost of goods sold and operating expenses 336.1 419.6 (83.5) (20)%





    Sales margin (loss) $(20) $46.1 $(66.1) (143)%
  • Revenue from product sales and services decreased by $149.6 million, primarily due to decreased sales volume due to blast furnace outages, and lower average sales price realization, reflecting lower pellet pricing and the mix of contracts. The decrease in cost of goods sold and operating expenses was not proportional to the decrease in sales volume due to fixed costs incurred during production curtailments to balance production with the lower sales volume.
  • Higher pre-operating losses from CAL, $6.8 million, reflecting start-up and commissioning costs on CAL’s HBI project in Trinidad and Tobago.
  • Higher interest expense, $3.3 million, resulting from the cessation of interest capitalization when construction of the HBI facility was completed in April, 1999.
  • Lower interest income, $2.1 million, due to lower average cash balances throughout the year.
  • Lower royalty and management fees in 1999, including amounts paid by the Company as a participant in the mining ventures, $1.2 million, mainly due to lower production.
  • Partially offsetting was lower administrative, selling and general expense, $2.6 million, including lower management incentive compensation, cost reduction initiatives and a 10 percent reduction of corporate staff in the first quarter of 1999.
  • Other expenses also decreased $3.9 million, including lower business development expenses and an increase in the allowance for doubtful accounts recorded in 1998 related to the Acme bankruptcy.

The $20.4 million decrease in income taxes before special items was primarily due to the decrease in pretax income and the favorable impact of percentage depletion.

Top of Page | Next Page